Image Source : INDIA TV Opinion | Why ‘some forces’ are not looking for the farmers to return house
Talks between the Centre and farm union leaders nearly collapsed on Friday after the latter conveyed to the federal government that they’d not comply with something in need of a repeal of the three controversial legal guidelines. On its half, the Centre hardened its stand saying that the supply to droop the operation of the three legal guidelines for one and half yr was the one greatest deal doable and repealing the legal guidelines was out of query.
Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar appeared unhappy on Friday after the assembly. He stated, it seems that there are some forces which are not looking for an answer to evolve and are attempting to serve their very own political pursuits by prolonging the agitation. No contemporary date was set for the following spherical of talks indicating that the matter is heading in the direction of a useless finish.
At Friday’s assembly, the ministers repeatedly requested the farm leaders to rethink the federal government’s supply to maintain the farm legal guidelines on maintain, however the latter had been adamant. They clearly stated that there may very well be no progress in talks if the legal guidelines weren’t repealed. The authorities replied that the supply to droop the legal guidelines was the one doable resolution, and there was no different supply to be made.
Friday’s assembly was the eleventh one within the sequence. I keep in mind, on the finish of each spherical of talks until the tenth one, Tomar used to return out with a smiling face to say that he was nonetheless hopeful of a breakthrough. But on Friday, after the eleventh spherical, he appeared unhappy and downcast. He minced no phrases when he stated why the talks failed. He stated, ‘this is what happens, when the sanctity of a movement ends and self-seekers start dominating’.
Farm union leaders had already introduced on Thursday night that they had been rejecting the federal government’s supply and the result of Friday’s assembly was a foregone conclusion. After the talks failed, many of the farmer leaders additionally appeared sad. One of them stated, they’d meet once more on Saturday, however the January 26 tractor rally will certainly happen. One hardliner farm union chief Gurnam Singh Chadhuni stated that the assembly was virtually over inside half an hour, when the ministers informed them that the suspension of legal guidelines was the one very best deal and it was as much as the farmers to determine. The ministers went away asking farm leaders to debate amongst themselves. Chadhuni stated, ‘we were unnecessary asked to wait when the talks had ended after half an hour’.
Hannan Mollah, the Left-leaning farmer chief, who used to talk to media after each spherical of talks, additionally appeared unhappy. On Friday, his response was: “What can we do? There was no breakthrough. We will convey our views to the government by 12 noon tomorrow”.
U.P. farmer chief Rakesh Tikait stated, ‘we will discuss among ourselves. If required, we will talk with the government, otherwise the agitation will continue.’ Another Bhartiya Kisan Union chief Yudhveer Singh stated, ‘for the moment, the path of talks is closed, the government has said, this is the last meeting. If the government refuses to repeal the laws, the agitation will continue.’
I believe, the federal government had given the supply to droop the farm legal guidelines for 18 months as a way to give the farm leaders a face-saver in order that they may return house and inform their supporters that they’ve secured a win. The agitation would have ended and the status of the farm leaders would have remained intact. There was no political skullduggery concerned on a part of the federal government. The supply was given solely after among the farm leaders had, in closed door conferences, informed the federal government that this may very well be a doable means out.
But the way by which the farm leaders responded on Thursday and Friday clearly reveals that the confrontationists amongst them had an higher hand. Such a scenario happens when there are a number of leaders heading an agitation. Their response clearly confirmed that there have been many among the many farmer leaders who had been in favour of retaining the farm legal guidelines beneath suspension as a result of it was going to profit the farmers in the long term. But there are parts among the many farm leaders who wish to additional their very own pursuits greater than these of the farmers. These parts wish to browbeat and denigrate the federal government. These parts are unwilling to just accept any center path and need the agitation to proceed. They have been repeatedly asserting that the January 26 tractor rally will happen. Their solely motive is to create strain on the federal government.
I do know there are a number of among the many farm leaders who are usually not in favour of a tractor rally to spoil Republic Day celebrations, however within the present scenario, they can’t ask farmers to cease their rally. Leaders who promise that the tractor rally shall be peaceable, have no idea themselves that there is no such thing as a assure that the rally might stay beneath their management, just like the case the place a breakthrough in talks was beneath management of a single particular person.
History has witnessed many mass actions, which had been greater and extra violent, however on the finish, dialogue was the one means out that offered options. My enchantment to the farmer leaders is: don’t snap off the thread of dialogue, the interval of 18 months isn’t too small, they need to settle for the federal government’s supply. There is little chance of them accepting this suggestion.
Tomar was proper when he stated there are some forces which are not looking for a breakthrough. It was evident on Friday, when quickly after the talks ended, Punjab chief minister Capt Amarinder Singh made a politically loaded assertion from Chandigarh. He introduced Rs 5 lakh help and a job to 1 member of the households of these farmers who turned ‘martyrs’ throughout the agitation. The CM alleged that BJP was throttling democracy, the Centre was detached to the pleas of farmers, however his authorities in Punjab is not going to go away the farmers in lurch.
The individuals of India have full sympathy in the direction of the households of these farmers who died throughout the agitation, and the Punjab CM’s announcement of help was welcome. But the timing and intent of this assertion elevate suspicions. Since the start of the agitation, Capt. Amarinder Singh was extending full help to the agitators and he wished the agitation to extend.
His occasion chief Rahul Gandhi and his MPs staged protests, went to the President, and gave statements each day in help of the agitation. In between, Rahul took time without work to rejoice New Year overseas, got here again and watched Jallikattu bull battle in Tamil Naadu, and thru Twitter, he each day prolonged his help to farmers, whereas deriding Modi. He exhorted the farmers to march forward like ‘warriors’ and his occasion working committee handed decision in help of the agitation.
In the backdrop of all this, one can simply perceive to whom was Narendra Singh Tomar referring to as “some forces”, who are not looking for the farmers to return to their properties. It is now for the farmers sitting on the outskirts of Delhi to determine.
WATCH AAJ KI BAAT:
Aaj Ki Baat: Monday to Friday, 9 PM
India’s Number One and essentially the most adopted Super Prime Time News Show ‘Aaj Ki Baat – Rajat Sharma Ke Saath was launched just before the 2014 General Elections. Since its inception, the show is redefining India’s super-prime time and is numerically far forward of its contemporaries.
Latest India News
