For salaried staff, advantages or perquisites obtained from the employer have at all times been taxable as salaries, and subjected to tax deduction at supply (TDS). Similarly, a profit or perquisite derived by a enterprise or occupation was additionally taxable. However, until this yr’s finances, there was no requirement for the supplier to deduct TDS on the worth of such profit or perquisite.
The scope of TDS has been prolonged from 1st July 2022 by this finances to use to such advantages or perquisites offered to an individual carrying on enterprise or occupation by an individual carrying on a enterprise or occupation with turnover above ₹1 crore or ₹50 lakh respectively, by insertion of a brand new provision.
While at first look it appeared that the target of the brand new provision was to topic such advantages obtained by a enterprise or occupation additionally to TDS, the next pointers point out the broad sweep of the brand new provision. Further, usually, a round issued by the CBDT is simply binding on the tax authorities and never on taxpayers, who’re free to take a distinct authorized view from that expressed within the round. Under the brand new provision, the rules issued by the CBDT are binding on taxpayers as properly.
The first set of pointers issued in June 2022 clarified that after advantages are offered to an individual carrying on a enterprise or occupation exceeding ₹20,000 a yr, TDS must be deducted by the supplier, with out checking whether or not such profit or perquisite is taxable or not. Further, whereas solely advantages or perquisites obtained in type are taxable, the rules require TDS even the place the profit or perquisite is a financial cost. Fortunately, gross sales low cost, money low cost and rebates allowed to prospects on gross sales, in addition to schemes similar to “purchase one, get one free” have been excluded from the TDS purview.
Free medical samples offered to hospitals or medical doctors are topic to TDS, although the physician or hospital would already successfully be paying tax on this, because the charges charged to sufferers to whom such medicines got can be mirrored as earnings, whereas medication price claimed as deduction can be nil. Products given to social media influencers would additionally appeal to this TDS. Reimbursement of out-of-pocket bills are additionally topic to such TDS (except falling underneath the pure agent class underneath GST), although successfully such receipts might already be topic to tax. Benefits offered by way of supplier conferences would even be taxed, to the extent of the profit offered, which has been clarified within the pointers.
Fortunately, it has been clarified that challenge of bonus or rights shares by a listed firm wouldn’t be topic to TDS. Unfortunately, this clarification has been restricted to such points by a listed firm or its subsidiary. As held by the Supreme Court in lots of circumstances, a bonus or rights challenge doesn’t lead to any profit to the shareholder, as there’s a corresponding fall within the worth of his current shareholding. So, even for unlisted corporations, the identical logic ought to observe.
It is unlucky that the scope of TDS is being made so extensive, with vital ambiguity. The truth of whether or not a profit is offered or not extremely subjective, and is prone to invite substantial litigation. Businesses can be spending substantial effort and time in in search of to establish all circumstances the place these provisions apply, and should but miss out on figuring out some, with consequent penalties and curiosity. In most circumstances, such advantages have been already successfully struggling and being supplied to tax, and TDS on these merely will increase the compliance burden on the deductors.
Further, there appears to be no rationale for in search of to use TDS provisions to non-taxable advantages, aside from the float obtained by the Government in amassing tax and refunding it after a yr or so. If the target of TDS is to examine tax evasion, assortment of data by way of the Annual Information Returns, that are collated into the taxpayer-wise Annual Information Statements and Tax Information Statements is very efficient in checking non-disclosure of earnings by taxpayers.
Besides, whereas deducting TDS, the deductor is de facto appearing as an agent of the Government. The provisions of TDS should be crystal clear, as no deductor would want to appeal to litigation on account of finishing up this thankless burden of tax assortment. Such wide-ranging and subjective provisions shouldn’t kind a part of TDS regulation, the web of which is already so extensive.
Gautam Nayak is companion, CNK & Associates LLP.
Catch all of the Business News, Market News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on Live Mint.
Download The Mint News App to get Daily Market Updates.
More
Less
Subscribe to Mint Newsletters
* Enter a legitimate electronic mail
* Thank you for subscribing to our e-newsletter.
