The India-England Test experienced a moment of controversy on the opening day due to a contentious decision by umpire Kumar Dharmasena. The incident unfolded during the first session and drew criticism from various quarters.
The crucial moment occurred in the 13th over of India’s innings. Josh Tongue bowled a delivery that hit Indian batsman Sai Sudharsan on the pads, resulting in an LBW appeal. Dharmasena, the on-field umpire, turned down the appeal, which replays later confirmed was the correct call, as the ball had an inside edge. The controversy arose from Dharmasena’s gesture towards the England fielders before the review window closed. He seemed to indicate that the ball had touched the bat, potentially influencing England captain Ollie Pope’s decision against taking a review.
Social media users voiced their opinions, with many accusing Dharmasena of bias. The general sentiment was that an umpire should not indicate his reasoning before the fielding side considers DRS. Michael Atherton, the former England captain, also suggested that India might feel unfairly treated.
Earlier, England successfully used the review system to dismiss Indian opener Yashasvi Jaiswal. Despite Dharmasena’s correct call on the Sudharsan LBW, his gesture sparked debate about the umpire’s role and impartiality.