September 21, 2024

Report Wire

News at Another Perspective

A story of two farewell speeches: How PM Modi roasted Ansari and showered love on Azad on their final days

3 min read

This is a narrative of two Muslim parliamentarians retiring from India’s coveted parliament. One is a person whose coronary heart and soul visibly resides in India; an individual who’s a staunch advocate of patriotism, if not nationalism. The man is at the moment at loggerheads together with his celebration’s prime management. The different man has been honoured being one of many longest-serving Vice Presidents of the nation. This man’s coronary heart resides within the Middle East, and his thoughts is most positively engraved within the medieval ages. This is the story of senior Congress leaders Ghulam Nabi Azad and former Vice President Hamid Ansari, and the way each have been seen-off in starkly totally different atmospheres from the nation’s parliament.Prime Minister Narendra Modi is a central determine on this non-fiction thriller. While on one hand, PM Modi teared up and visibly received tremendously emotional whereas bidding goodbye to Ghulam Nabi Azad from the Rajya Sabha, 4 years in the past, he had taken to sarcastically obliterating Hamid Ansari, whereas his Vice Presidency, and consequently, chairmanship of the Rajya Sabha was coming to an finish. The length of the Prime Minister’s speech for Ghulam Nabi Azad, in distinction to his deal with to the Rajya Sabha, whereas bidding farewell to Ansari in itself speaks volumes concerning the worth hooked up by him to the 2 people. While PM Modi choked on his tears whereas talking about Ghulam Nabi Azad in a speech spanning over 14 minutes, he was stuffed with pleasure, wit and sarcasm whereas bidding adieu to Hamid Ansari. In 2017, PM Modi talked about Ansari’s Family legacy and elucidated how his household has been a household of “ardent Congress Workers” who additionally participated within the “Khilafat Movement”. PM Modi spoke about how Hamid Ansari had been a profession diplomat, most of whose time was spent within the “Middle East”, his “सोच का दायरा” (Way of considering) has been formed by his expertise there. PM Modi referred Hamid Ansari as a shiny alumnus of the “Prestigious Aligarh Muslim University and Jamia Milia Islamia” which additionally “enhanced” his mind-set. PM Modi then stated, “You must have felt some desperation…but after this day, even that won’t be a problem…there will be joy of freedom…and absolute independence to act or guide others according to your fundamental Beliefs”. The phrases within the double citation have been all sarcastic jibes taken by the Prime Minister on Ansari. Read extra: PM Modi completely demolished Hamid Ansari in his speech, The Sarcasm was DeadlyIn distinction, the speeches and remarks of many BJP leaders, starting with a minimum of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, left many political spectators and analysts stunned. The bonhomie between Azad and the Prime Minister was free-flowing, as each broke down whereas delivering their respective speeches on Tuesday. PM Modi, a minimum of took to saluting Azad, and recounting how the person was leaving a giant void to fill within the higher home. The Prime Minister additionally acknowledged that his doorways would at all times stay open for Ghulam Nabi Azad. Read extra: PM Modi tears up; Ghulam Nabi Azad assaults his personal celebration in his farewell speech in ParliamentAzad, in the meantime, stated that he was proud that he’s an “Indian Muslim”. “I am among those fortunate people who never went to Pakistan. When I read about circumstances in Pakistan, I feel proud to be a Hindustani Muslim.” The Indian Muslims believed in peaceable existence in contrast to strife and warfare in Muslim nations, he stated. With such statements, Azad successfully put to relaxation the Congress’ relentless “intolerance is on the rise” bogey. The remarks by Azad got here within the backdrop of former Vice President Hamid Ansari declaring in his new e book that Muslims felt insecure in India and that hyper-nationalism (of Hindus) was making India ‘intolerant’.Hamid Ansari’s retirement from parliamentary politics introduced tears to no eyes. As the Vice President, in contempt of the sanctity of the workplace he held, Ansari went on to say that there was a rising sense of insecurity among the many Muslims in India. He asserted the truth that the “ambience of acceptance” was now beneath siege. Such ridiculous insinuations by Ansari didn’t go down nicely with the BJP, particularly PM Modi, who took to ripping him aside when bidding him farewell from the parliament’s higher home.