Deported or Australian Open-bound? Possible outcomes from Novak Djokovic’s court docket battle with Australia

Seven days from the Australian Open, Novak Djokovic will take the court docket in a battle in opposition to the Australian authorities on Monday.
The world No. 1’s visa was cancelled upon arrival at Melbourne airport final week after Australian border officers dominated that he didn’t meet the standards for an exemption to an entry requirement that each one non-citizens be absolutely vaccinated for COVID-19. Djokovic has since spent 4 nights in an Australian immigration detention resort and his attorneys have since filed papers claiming he has the all-clear due to a optimistic Covid-19 check in December.

The highly-publicised case is scheduled for a web-based listening to in a federal court docket on Monday (10 am Melbourne time, 4:30 am IST).
The court docket and the choose
Formed final September, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia is the results of the merger of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia and the Family Court of Australia. Under the 2 divisions, the court docket has jurisdiction over household legislation issues — divorce functions, parenting disputes, property division — and over issues broadly referring to household legislation and little one help, administrative legislation, admiralty legislation, chapter, copyright, human rights, industrial legislation, migration, privateness and commerce practices.
After almost 30 years on the Bar, Anthony Kelly was appointed a choose of the federal circuit court docket in 2017. His prior apply options high-profile circumstances reminiscent of oil and fuel firm Exxon-Mobil’s litigation from the Longford explosions (1998-2008) and the Bank of Melbourne case (1990 to 1993).
On Sunday, Kelly refused Home Affairs Minister Karen Andrews’s request for Djokovic’s listening to to be postponed until Wednesday. The delay would have dominated Djokovic out of the Australian Open as Tennis Australia’s attorneys have mentioned it will have to know by Tuesday whether or not Djokovic might compete, for scheduling functions.
On Thursday, Judge Kelly had ordered minister Andrews to not deport Djokovic whereas he fights his attraction. Kelly had additionally enquired in regards to the tennis amenities on the immigration resort the place Djokovic is detained.
“I don’t think it’s unreasonable for the court to ask… whether the particular hotel at which the applicant is staying… might have available to him tennis practising facilities,” Kelly mentioned. “I don’t expect you to answer that, but it just seems a realistic question to pose.”
Supporters of Serbia’s Novak Djokovic dance outdoors the Park Hotel, used as an immigration detention resort the place Djokovic is confined in Melbourne, Australia, Sunday, Jan. 9, 2022.
If Djokovic wins
If choose Kelly decides in favour of Djokovic, the latter’s visa would turn into legitimate once more.
In a 35-page submission forward of the listening to, the Serb’s authorized staff known as for his “immediate release” from detention no later than 5:00 pm on Monday. They have additionally requested the choose to rule “at the earliest time possible”, with out ready to craft his authorized reasoning that they are saying may very well be launched later.
Arguing that Djokovic’s visa was wrongly cancelled and ought to be reinstated, permitting him to compete, his authorized staff claimed that he obtained a doc from the Department of Home Affairs seemingly clearing his approach into the nation. The paperwork say he had obtained a visa on November 18, examined optimistic for Covid-19 on December 16, and was offered the “Medical exemption from COVID vaccination on the ground that he had recently recovered from COVID” on December 30.

Serbian followers aren’t stopping. Singing a patriotic track “Tamo daleko” in entrance of the resort the place #Djokovic is at. pic.twitter.com/tt3CQlkIXL
— Saša Ozmo (@ozmo_sasa) January 8, 2022
If the Australian authorities wins
Djokovic will possible be deported on the following accessible flight out of Melbourne. Judge Kelly’s order to not take away Djokovic whereas he fights his attraction expires at 4:00 pm on Monday. Australian border officers have already dominated that he didn’t meet the standards for an exemption to an entry requirement that each one non-citizens be absolutely vaccinated in opposition to COVID-19.
Serbia’s Novak Djokovic, left, stands with Australian Open event director Craig Tiley throughout the trophy presentation on the Australian Open tennis championships in Melbourne, Australia, Sunday, Feb 21, 2021. (AP)
“The government has always been clear about what is necessary in terms of the entry requirements into Australia,” Federal Finance Minister Simon Birmingham instructed Today on Friday. “We made that clear to Tennis Australia. It’s been publicly clear for a long time. You have got to be double-vaccinated if you are not an Australian citizen to enter Australia when we open the borders.”
Legal skilled Christopher Levingston instructed AFP that the federal government’s case relied on a bit of migration legislation that he believes “will ultimately see Mr Djokovic fail in his application”. He continued that the minister solely has to indicate that the presence of the visa holder “may, would or might be” a threat to the well being, security or good order of Australians.
The appeals
According to authorized specialists, each events are anticipated to attraction the ruling.
If the federal government appeals, “Mr Djokovic would remain in immigration detention”, Levingston, an accredited specialist in migration legislation with greater than 20 years of expertise, mentioned.
Djokovic might additionally go for a problem if his case is dismissed, together with his attorneys flagging some untested level of legislation, John Findley, a solicitor-director who focuses on migration, household, enterprise and tax issues, instructed AFP.

According to Levingston, nevertheless, even when an attraction is lodged, Djokovic wouldn’t have the ability to stroll free. The choose couldn’t order the federal government to permit Djokovic to exit detention.
Other potentialities
Other specialists consider that the tennis star may very well be granted a reprieve.
Partner at Thomson Geer Lawyers, Justin Quill, instructed Today on Friday: “I think what’s going to occur is – and I think not a lot as a result of he’s going to win his case, however that it’ll be discovered that there wants (to be) extra time, and he can be allowed to remain within the nation, compete within the Australian Open, after which the attorneys will argue about this within the weeks and months to observe.
“The imposition on Djokovic not being allowed to compete is arguably greater than the imposition on the Minister for Home Affairs. So, I suspect the court is going to land there and say, ‘I’m going to allow you to stay in the country while we sort this out over the following weeks and months’,” Quill mentioned.

Djokovic is also barred from the nation for as much as three years, if he will get deported. In an emailed response to The Associated Press, the Australian Border Force mentioned: “A person whose visa has been cancelled may be subject to a three-year exclusion period that prevents the grant of a further temporary visa. The exclusion period will be considered as part of any new visa application and can be waived in certain circumstances, noting each case is assessed on its own merits.”