Tag: European Court of Human Rights

  • Tayyip Erdogan says Turkey won’t respect Council of Europe

    Turkey won’t respect the Council of Europe if it doesn’t respect Turkish courts, President Tayyip Erdogan mentioned on Thursday, when requested a few resolution to refer the case in opposition to philanthropist Osman Kavala again to a high European courtroom.
    Kavala, considered one of Turkey’s highest-profile detainees, has been held for greater than 4 years and not using a conviction.
    The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) dominated greater than two years in the past that Kavala must be launched instantly and mentioned his detention served to silence him, however Turkey has not carried out the ruling.
    The Council mentioned on Thursday that its committee had referred the case to the ECHR to find out whether or not Turkey has failed to satisfy its obligation to implement the courtroom’s judgment, in keeping with the European Convention on Human Rights.

    The referral to the ECHR is the subsequent step in “infringement proceedings” that would end in Turkey’s suspension from the Council of Europe, of which it’s a founding member.
    Ayse Bugra, spouse of philanthropist Osman Kavala, talks to the media in entrance of the courthouse after a listening to of Kavala and 15 others over their position in nationwide protests in 2013, in Istanbul, Turkey, November 26, 2021. REUTERS/Umit Bektas/File Photo
    “The Committee found that, by failing to ensure Mr Kavala’s immediate release, Turkey is refusing to abide by the Court’s final judgment in his case,” it mentioned in an announcement.

    At a information convention, Erdogan mentioned Turkey won’t recognise those that don’t recognise its courts.
    “What the ECHR has said, what the Council of Europe says, this doesn’t concern us much because we expect our courts to be respected,” he mentioned.

    “To those who don’t show this respect: excuse us, but we will have no respect for them either,” Erdogan added.
    The overseas ministry mentioned on Wednesday that Turkey had carried out the ECHR ruling and that Kavala was detained for a distinct judicial continuing.

    Kavala was acquitted in 2020 of fees associated to 2013 nationwide protests. Hours later, one other courtroom ordered his arrest based mostly on a cost of trying to overthrow the constitutional order associated to the 2016 coup try, which the ECHR had additionally mentioned lacked foundation.
    That courtroom later dominated to launch him on that cost however ordered his detention on an espionage cost in the identical case, a transfer critics mentioned was geared toward circumventing the ECHR ruling.

  • Caster Semenya taking case to European Court of Human Rights

    Caster Semenya goes to the European Court of Human Rights to problem “discriminatory” guidelines that prohibit her from competing in sure monitor occasions due to her excessive pure testosterone, her attorneys mentioned Thursday.
    The two-time Olympic champion within the 800 meters has already misplaced two authorized appeals towards World Athletics’ rules that drive her to medically decrease her pure testosterone stage if she needs to run in ladies’s races from 400 meters to 1 mile.
    The South African’s attorneys mentioned there’s been a “violation of her rights” and desires the human rights courtroom to look at the foundations.
    Semenya has considered one of numerous circumstances often called variations of intercourse growth. Although she has by no means publicly launched particulars of her situation, World Athletics has controversially referred to her as “biologically male” in earlier authorized proceedings, an outline that angered Semenya.
    Semenya has the everyday male XY chromosome sample and ranges of testosterone which are a lot greater then the everyday feminine vary, World Athletics says. The monitor and subject physique says that offers her and different athletes like her an unfair benefit over different feminine runners.
    The 30-year-old Semenya was legally recognized as feminine at start and has recognized as feminine her entire life. She says her testosterone is merely a genetic present.
    The rules have been fiercely criticized, primarily due to the “treatment” choices World Athletics offers to permit affected athletes to compete. They have considered one of three choices to decrease their testosterone ranges: Taking every day contraceptive capsules, utilizing hormone-blocking injections, or having surgical procedure.
    “The regulations require these women to undergo humiliating and invasive physical examinations followed by harmful and experimental medical procedures if they wish to compete internationally in women’s events between 400m and one mile, the exact range in which Ms. Semenya specializes,” Semenya’s attorneys mentioned.
    World Athletics, which was then often called the IAAF, introduced in 2018 it could introduce the foundations. Semenya challenged them and misplaced on the Court of Arbitration for Sport in 2019. She additionally misplaced a second enchantment to the Swiss Federal Tribunal final yr. That second case will probably be central to her enchantment to the European Court of Human Rights.
    “Caster asks the Court to find that Switzerland has failed in its positive obligations to protect her against the violation of her rights under the European Convention on Human Rights,” her attorneys mentioned.
    They mentioned the monitor physique’s guidelines have been “discriminatory attempts to restrict the ability of certain women to participate in female athletics competitions.”
    Because of her refusal to decrease her pure testosterone, Semenya has been barred from working within the 800 since 2019, when she was the dominant runner on the earth over two laps. She is presently not allowed to run her favourite race _ the race she has gained two Olympic golds and three world titles in _ at any main occasion.
    Semenya shouldn’t be the one athlete affected. Two different Olympic medalists from Africa, Francine Niyonsaba of Burundi and Margaret Wambui of Kenya, have mentioned they’re additionally sure by the foundations. They additionally mentioned they’d refuse to endure medical intervention to cut back their testosterone ranges.
    “I hope the European court will put an end to the longstanding human rights violations by World Athletics against women athletes,” Semenya mentioned in a press release. “All we ask is to be allowed to run free, for once and for all.”
    Semenya, Niyonsaba and Wambui completed 1-2-3 within the 800 meters on the 2016 Rio de Janeiro Olympics, strengthening World Athletics’ argument that their medical circumstances gave them an athletic benefit over different ladies.
    It’s unclear if the human rights courtroom would be capable to hear Semenya’s case earlier than the delayed Tokyo Olympics, which is perhaps Semenya’s final. The video games are set to open on July 23. Previous sports activities circumstances which have gone to the European Court of Human Rights have taken years to be determined.